Why I’ve Moved From Team Pantser to Team Plotter

There’s an age old debate amongst writers: do you plan, or do you pants?

To plan or not to plan… that is the question – Definitely Not Shakespeare

Well, I was firmly on Team Pantser prior to writing my first novel, for the following reasons:

  • If I plan the story before I write it, it’ll feel like I’ve written it and I’ll lose my motivation to flesh the bullet points into a living, breathing book
  • Planning doesn’t leave any space for spontaneous actions on the part of my characters! I want my books to be character-led, so I need to keep them in the driving seat
  • Planning takes forever and I just want to get on down and write


I tell you what though.

When you have 100k words sitting in front of you that starts strongly, peters off significantly in the middle and kind of rushes together at the end, planning starts to look appealing.

Fixing a plot point when you have six pages of bullet points in front of you is daunting.

Fixing a plot point where you have 100k words of an interconnecting story is a hell of a lot worse. 

Which is why I think there are streams of reformed pantsers all over the writerly internet. 

Pantsing means when something goes wrong… it goes really wrong


As you write, you weave your story together. The set of things your characters know or don’t know comes together as you write, so if you suddenly decide that actually, your characters probably shouldn’t open that letter in this scene, they should do it three scenes later, it throws everything else out of whack.

Now you’re going back and editing dialogue, motivations, conflicts, disasters… the whole lot.

In fact, it’s such a large and unwieldy process I have (for now) consigned my 100k word not-quite-a-novel to my Scrivener drafts and moved onto planning something else.

So if there’s one thing I can promise you, it’s whatever energy and sweat you put into the pain of planning will pay back in dividends when you get around to having to edit it.

But if, like me, you’ve been Team Pantser all your life, where the hell do you begin?

Well, here are my top 5 blog posts about planning your novel (with particular kudos to the blogs by K.M. Weiland, I use her methods religiously now and so far, they’re really paying off!)

Five Blogs That Convinced Me To Plot:


  1. How To Outline Your Novel
  2. How To Craft Strong Character Arcs
  3. How To Use Foreshadowing
  4. Scenes and Sequences Within Your Novel
  5. Defining Theme In Your Novel

If these guys don’t convince you, then how about…

Five More Reasons To Consider Switching Alliegances:

people-men-grass-sport.jpgForeshadowing becomes a hell of a lot easier when you plot

You want things to come as a surprise, but you don’t want stuff to come out of the blue. If your character is going to be heading off against Big Baddie Number Two at some point, you need to foreshadow this (and at the very least introduce us to this character nice and early on).

Foreshadowing = tension = the reader keeps reading.

Writing is a lot easier with a map

We all know that feeling when you sit down to write, and you look at your document, and the little line starting flashing at you… and then an hour passes and you’re in the same position?

Well, that doesn’t happen so much once you’ve planned.

I’m not going to lie and tell you it doesn’t happen at all because you’ve got to come up with the plot somehow, but it means your flashy-line anxiety is dealt with right from the beginning, and not from the end.

Editing is easier

I think you get the picture. Everything. Becomes. Easier.



7 Replies to “Why I’ve Moved From Team Pantser to Team Plotter”

  1. Very helpful! I tend to go back and forth, although I do lean towards planning since it tends to help to have a fairly good idea of where I am going.


    1. Definitely! Mapping it out before hand seems to prevent writer’s block for me. Although it doesn’t mean I don’t get stuck with it in the planning phase… !


Share your thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.